20 Creepy Halloween Party Foods

If you’re going to do Halloween right, you gotta have some creepy food.  It’s the one night of the year that I don’t mind when my kids say, “That looks disgusting!” when we’re eating dinner.  The list I’ve compiled would be awesome if you’re having a Halloween party, but maybe pick one to make just for the family on Halloween, right before Trick or Treating.  I’ve pulled together 20 Creepy Halloween Party Foods to inspire you!

20 Creepy Halloween Party Foods

Halloween Cocktail Meatball Eyes

Halloween Meatball Eyes from Everyday Dishes

Might as well kick this off right with some super creepy Meatballs.  Yes, they look disgusting, but they also kind of look delicious, don’t they??

Halloween Witch Hat Cupcakes and more Halloween Food Crafts for Kids. These are fun for an October Birthday or to bring in the classroom as a Halloween Dessert. Recipe on Frugal Coupon Living.

Halloween Witch Hat Cupcakes from Frugal Coupon Living

Ok, someone is brilliant!  Flip your ice cream cone over and you have a witch hat!!  So smart and these are too adorable.

These tissue paper pumpkin favours are a great treat to send to school on Halloween or they make super cute party favours! Use them for any fall occasion!

Easy Tissue Paper Pumpkin Treat Bags

These are too cute!  If you really have a lot of time on your hands you could put a bunch of these together for your trick-or-treaters.  Or maybe your kids classmates?

Halloween Lasagna from Mommy on the Money

This is scary.  I mean really scary.  I might have to sleep with the light on tonight.


Zombie Eyeballs from Eighteen25

If you’ve never made these candy and pretzel treats, let these be the first one’s you try.  There are tons of variations for every holiday and the salty sweet combo is totally addictive.

These Halloween Mummy Pizza Bites are adorable and incredibly easy to make! Your kids will love them for your next Halloween Party!

Halloween Mummy Pizzas from The Printable Crush

If it has the word pizza in it, my kids will eat it.  They probably won’t even notice that these are in the shape of mummies.

Okay these mummy brownies are so freaking adorable! They are easy to make, freaking delicious, and my kids couldn't stop raving about them! Definitely a new Halloween tradition!

Easy Mummy Brownies from Pretty Providence

Sticking with the mummy theme, how about these brownies?  You don’t even really need to actually bake brownies, you just need to cover them with white icing.  (Don’t worry, I won’t tell anyone you cheated!).

Easy 4-ingredient bat treats for Halloween

Mini Chocolate Bats from Chelsea’s Messy Apron

Bats scream Halloween, right?  These sweet ones won’t bite back!

Halloween fun. Out and about...[ K-Tor.com ]

Cheese Graveyard and Brie Cofffin from Makezine

If you’re looking for something a little more sophisticated for Halloween, this cheese tray has got you covered.  Spider Cupcakes

Spider Cupcakes from Texan Erin

Here’s what’s great about these.  Cupcakes aren’t really hard to make, neither is the spider shown above.  But, these are totally the thing that everyone will ooh and ahh over at the Halloween bake sale.  The recipe from Texan Erin is gluten free, btw, if you’re interested!

These healthier bloody witch fingers use jam in place of food coloring! Can be made with all-purpose flour or with whole wheat for a 100% whole grain version. The perfect Halloween recipe!

Witches Fingers from Texan Erin 

Two in a row from Texan Erin, well played Erin.  These healthier witches fingers are totally creepy, but also very appetizing.

Halloween Treat: Cheese and Pretzel Broomsticks. These are so easy and such a cute idea for a Halloween themed treat!

Cheese And Pretzel Broomsticks from One Little Project

I actually made these cuties for a Girl Scouts Halloween Party several years ago and they were a hit.  It’s nice to have something that’s not chocolate on chocolate on peanut butter on chocolate.  You know, cleanse the palate and all that.

Chicken Boo-dle Soup from Morgan Manages Mommyhood

Oh, this wins.  This soup is totally my favorite.  First of all, it’s not as complicated as it looks which is always a good thing.  This is happening in my house.

FINGERS IN A BUN ~ Halloween lol! Maybe make it a chili dog, didn't they find a finger in chili?

Hot Dog Fingers from Party Tipz

Oh my God, those are totally disgusting.  AND PERFECT!  I’ll eat the chicken soup on Halloween night and my kids will eat these nasty things.

Mini Spider Pizzas | Recipe Runner | Spooky fun mini pizzas using delicious black olives! #CalOlivesHalloween #CleverGirls

Mini Spider Pizzas from Recipe Runner

Another creepy pizza.  I guess I’m not the only one with pizza fanatics!

Ghosts in the Graveyard Dessert Shooters - I love how these are individual, and made from scratch!

Ghosts in the Graveyard Dessert Shooters from Sugar Spun Run

Ok, if there are Milano cookies involved, I’m totally in.

I love taco dip, so why not creep it out for Halloween?

These rice krispie treat pumpkins are ADORABLE and they're really easy to make! They'd be perfect for a Halloween party snack, or even Thanksgiving!

Rice Krispie Treat Pumpkins from One Little Project

These win the award for most adorable, in my opinion.

With Halloween sneaking up on us, I’m sure you’ll be attending some parties. The kids are sure going to go nuts over these Halloween deviled eggs.

Deliciously Rotten Deviled Eggs from Parenting Chaos

Am I the only lucky parent who got a kid that loves Deviled Eggs?  I feel like most kids would not eat these, but my daughter loves them!

Have I whet your creepy appetite?  I can’t wait to try some of these out!

Don’t forget to Pin It!

Leave a Comment